Supreme Court Videos

Video recordings of oral arguments heard in Nashville before the Tennessee Supreme Court are available to view approximately 21 days after the oral argument. You may access the video by clicking on the case number listed below.

 2023     2022      2021          2020          2019           2018

Cases were live-streamed to the TN Courts YouTube page.

February 21st, 2024
Robert E. Lee Flade v. City of Shelbyville, Tennessee et al.
Plaintiff-Appellee Robert E. Lee Flade filed this action against multiple defendants, including Defendants-Appellants Stephanie Isaacs and the Bedford County Listening Project (“BCLP”).  Mr. Flade alleged that Ms. Isaacs, acting on behalf of BCLP, helped coordinate a public campaign to harass him regarding the condition of a rental house he owned.  The complaint asserted that this conduct “amounted to libel per se, intentional interference with business, intentional infliction of emotional distress, stalking and harassment.”  In response to the complaint, Ms. Isaacs and BCLP filed petitions to dismiss pursuant to the Tennessee Public Participation Act (“TPPA”).  Before the petitions were heard, Mr. Flade filed a notice of voluntary dismissal.  Defendants filed notices of intent to proceed with their petitions despite the dismissal.  The trial court declined to adjudicate the TPPA petitions in light of the nonsuit, and the Court of Appeals affirmed.  The Tennessee Supreme Court granted review to address whether a defendant’s TPPA petition survives a plaintiff’s nonsuit.  

February 21st, 2024
Annie J. Jones, By and Through Her Conservatorship, Joyce Sons a/k/a Calisa Joyce Sons v. Life Care Centers of America d/b/a Life Care Center of Tullahoma
Annie Jones was a resident of Life Care Center of Tullahoma.  A Life Care employee was assisting Ms. Jones with taking a shower when the employee received a video call from her incarcerated boyfriend.  When the employee answered the video call, Ms. Jones’s nude body was visible to the caller.  Ms. Jones’s daughter, acting as Ms. Jones’s conservator, initiated this action against Life Care alleging that that “[a]s a direct and proximate result of the grossly negligent, willful, wanton, reckless, malicious and/or intentional misconduct of defendant, plaintiff’s privacy and dignity were violated.”  While the action was pending, Ms. Jones died.  Life Care moved for summary judgment, asserting a lack of injury and damages.  The trial court granted Life Care’s motion for summary judgment, finding that the Plaintiff could not prove the existence of any cognizable injury or damages.  Plaintiff appealed.  The Court of Appeals instructed the parties to file additional briefing addressing whether an action for invasion of privacy can be maintained after the death of the individual whose privacy was invaded.  After each party filed briefs on the issue, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s grant of summary judgment on the issue of injury and damages and further held that the claim for invasion of privacy based on intrusion upon seclusion survived the death of Ms. Jones.  The Tennessee Supreme Court granted Life Care’s application for permission to appeal to address the issue of whether a claim for invasion of privacy for intrusion upon seclusion survives the death of the individual whose privacy was invaded.