Cynthia E. Yebuah, Et Al. v. Center For Urological Treatment, PLC - Dissenting

Case Number: M2018-01652-SC-R11-CV

This case illustrates how the damages cap statute, Tennessee Code Annotated section 29-39-102, deprives injured plaintiffs of fair compensation by arbitrarily limiting their awards for noneconomic damages. Cynthia Yebuah and her husband, Eric Yebuah, suffered noneconomic damages because of the carelessness of Mrs. Yebuah’s surgeon. Based on the evidence at trial, a jury awarded Mrs. Yebuah more than $750,000 in noneconomic damages for her pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life and awarded Mr. Yebuah less than $750,000 for his loss of consortium. The issue here is whether the trial court must apply the $750,000 statutory cap on noneconomic damages separately to each of the Yebuahs’ awards or to the combined total of their awards. If the cap is applied separately to each award, the trial court must slash the jury’s verdict to Mrs. Yebuah by 81% and allow Mr. Yebuah to recover all of the damages the jury awarded him. If the cap is applied to the combined total of the awards, then the trial court must cut the total award to the Yebuahs by 83%. Neither application can withstand constitutional scrutiny. I decline to choose between these two alternatives; both are unconstitutional violations of the Yebuahs’ right to trial by jury. See McClay v. Airport Mgmt. Servs., LLC, 596 S.W.3d 686, 701–09 (Tenn. 2020) (Lee, J., dissenting). 

Authoring Judge: Justice Sharon G. Lee with whom Justice Cornelia A. Clark, joins
Originating Judge: Judge Joseph P. Binkley, Jr.
Case Name: Cynthia E. Yebuah, Et Al. v. Center For Urological Treatment, PLC - Dissenting
Date Filed:
Dissent or Concur: This is a dissenting opinion
Download PDF Version: yebuahcynthia.sep_.opn_.pdf106.97 KB