Case Number
              E2004-02858-CCA-R3-CD
          I agree with the majority that this case is not properly before this court for an appeal as of right pursuant to Tennessee Rule of Appellate Procedure 3 and that it does not qualify as an extraordinary appeal under Tennessee Rule of Appellate Procedure 10. I write separately because it is my view that the dismissal of the state appeal might imply that evidence obtained from a vehicle's event data recorder (the air bag sensor module) is generally inadmissible.
Originating Judge
              Judge James B. Scott, Jr.
          Case Name
              State of Tennessee v. Shannon A. Holladay - Concurring
          Date Filed
              Dissent or Concur
              No
          Download PDF Version
              HolladaySCON.pdf25.08 KB