Guy Wilson, et al. v. Thompson Const. Co., et al.
M2000-03200-COA-R3-CV
This is a suit by Guy Wilson and his wife Rhessa, owners of a building in Gallatin, Tennessee, against their general contractor in the construction of an addition to the building and against their electrical subcontractor. The complaint charges negligence in the use of a defective fiberglass ladder that broke as Guy Wilson was climbing on it to inspect the work. The trial court held that the general contractor, Thompson Construction Company, had breached no duty of care to Plaintiffs and that the electrical contractor, Gary R. Boyd, was an independent contractor for whose alleged negligence Thompson Construction Company was not vicariously liable. On such basis, the trial court granted summary judgment to Thompson Construction Company on all issues and, pursuant to Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure 54.02, entered final judgment on all issues in favor of Thompson Construction Company. Plaintiffs appeal, and we affirm the trial court.
Authoring Judge: Judge William B. Cain
Originating Judge:C. L. Rogers |
Sumner County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
American Child Care, Inc. v. Dept. of Human Services, et al.
M2000-01790-COA-R3-CV
This appeal arises from the trial court's denial of appellant American Child Care, Inc.'s, request for attorney's fees resulting from an administrative action in which appellant's license was suspended and later reinstated. The trial court later granted appellee summary judgment on all issues, including attorney's fees. We reverse the trial court's decision denying the appellant's application and remand to the trial court to set a reasonable fee for the appellant.
Authoring Judge: Judge Ben H. Cantrell
Originating Judge:Ellen Hobbs Lyle |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
John Warfield, et ux vs. Carlos Lowe, et al
E2001-01042-COA-R3-CV
Plaintiff sought to establish insurance coverage for his injuries under his employer's policy. The Trial Judge declared no coverage. On appeal, we affirm.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Herschel P. Franks
Originating Judge:James B. Scott, Jr. |
Anderson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Janet Harper, et al. v. Keith Churn, et al.
M2000-02353-COA-R3-CV
This is a personal injury case arising from a vehicular collision. The plaintiffs, the Harpers, and the defendants, Mr. Churn and Mr. Beard, along with several others, were traveling together in a rented vehicle at the time of the collision. Mr. Churn was the driver of the vehicle; Mr. Beard was the pastor of the parties' church. At trial, the Harpers asserted that Mr. Churn was negligent in his operation of the vehicle. Additionally, the Harpers claimed that Mr. Beard was vicariously liable for their injuries, or in the alternative, that Mr. Beard was liable under the theory of negligent entrustment. The trial court granted Mr. Beard's motion for a directed verdict, and the jury found in favor of Mr. Churn. The Harpers appeal both decisions. We affirm the judgment of the trial court.
Authoring Judge: Judge David R. Farmer
Originating Judge:Hamilton V. Gayden, Jr. |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Forrest Cate Motor v. Dealer Computer Services
M2001-01577-COA-R3-CV
Plaintiff appeals a declaratory judgment wherein the trial judge held that the mandatory arbitration provisions in the contract between the parties controlled and declared accordingly. We affirm.
Authoring Judge: Judge William B. Cain
Originating Judge:Buddy D. Perry |
Sequatchie County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Charles Hardy, et al. v. Robert Miller, et al.
M1998-00940-COA-R3-CV
This appeal involves a dispute among members of a joint venture regarding their rights under suretyship agreements each member signed to guarantee a loan to the joint venture. After the joint venture defaulted, the bank looked to the members of the joint venture for payment of the debt. After three members of the joint venture paid the bank more than their prorated share of the debt, they filed suit in the Chancery Court for Davidson County against a former member, seeking contribution for the amount they had paid in excess of their prorated share. The former member counterclaimed, seeking to recover the payments he had made to the bank on the joint venture's debt. Following a bench trial, the trial court concluded that the members were co-sureties, awarded the three members a $150,145.10 judgment against the former member, and denied the former member's counterclaim. The former member appealed, arguing that his former co-venturers lost their right to contribution when they expelled him from the joint venture and that he is entitled to be reimbursed for the payments he made to the bank on the joint venture's debt. We have determined that each member of the joint venture agreed to be severally liable to the bank for the joint venture's debt and, therefore, that the members were not entitled to contribution from the former member. We have also concluded that the trial court correctly dismissed the former member's counterclaim.
Authoring Judge: Judge William C. Koch, Jr.
Originating Judge:Carol L. Mccoy |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
William Patrick Varley, Jr., v. Pamela Dawn Varley
01A01-9511-CV-00498
This is a divorce action wherein the appellant, Pamela Dawn Varley (Wife), appeals from the final decree which awarded a divorce and sole custody of the parties’ three minor children to Appellee, William Patrick Varley, Jr. (Husband). The children are Bridget Marie, born December 14, 1988, William Patrick Varley, III, born January 23, 1991 and Sadie Ellen Varley, whose date of birth is June 30, 1992. The decree also fails to award Wife alimony.
Authoring Judge: Judge David R. Farmer
Originating Judge:Judge Muriel Robinson |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Anthony Myers, et al. v. Allen Bryan, III
M2000-03188-COA-R3-CV
This case originated as a suit against a subdivision developer, W. Allen Bryan, III, ("Bryan"), for fraud, negligent misrepresentation, and violation of the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act, all predicated on the failure of a subdivision plat plan to reflect an existing drainage easement. Thereafter, Bryan filed a third-party complaint seeking indemnification from the surveyor who prepared the plat plan, Ragan-Smith, Associates, Inc. ("Ragan-Smith"), in the event Bryan was cast in judgment. On this Tenn. R. App. P. 54.02 appeal, we are presented with the issue of whether Bryan's cause of action for failure to reflect the drainage easement on the plat plan is barred by the four-year statute of repose for surveying errors. The court below granted Ragan-Smith summary judgment, finding that Bryan's claim is barred by the aforesaid statute of repose. Bryan appeals, arguing that Ragan-Smith is not entitled to summary judgment because, according to Bryan, the omission of the drainage easement is an engineering error, not a surveying error, and hence, so the argument goes, the subject claim is not barred by the four-year statute of repose for surveying errors. In the alternative, Bryan argues that even if the failure to reflect the drainage easement on the plat plan is a surveying error, his third-party complaint was timely filed. We affirm.
Authoring Judge: Judge Charles D. Susano, Jr.
Originating Judge:Russell Heldman |
Williamson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Cynthia Long vs. City of Maryville
E2001-00908-COA-R3-CV
Upon remand from this Court, the Trial Court entered Judgment for defendant in this slip and fall case. On appeal, we reverse.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Herschel P. Franks
Originating Judge:W. Dale Young |
Blount County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
In re: Estate of M.L. Wakefield, Deceased
M1998-00921-COA-R3-CV
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Patricia J. Cottrell
Originating Judge:Frank G. Clement, Jr. |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/10/01 | |
Willa Jean Gaskill v. Steven Wayne Gaskill
01A01-9512-CH-00559
This appeal involves the custody of a four-year-old girl. After slightly more than two years of marriage, the mother filed a divorce petition in the Chancery Court for Montgomery County requesting custody of the parties’ only child. Following a bench trial, the trial court declared the parties divorced and awarded custody to the mother. The husband asserts on this appeal that he is comparatively more fit than the mother to have custody. We agree and, therefore, reverse the trial court’s award of custody to the mother.
Authoring Judge: Judge William C. Koch, Jr.
Originating Judge:Judge John H. Gasaway, III |
Montgomery County | Court of Appeals | 12/07/01 | |
Austin Powder Co., et al., v. Walter Thompson
03A01-9607-CV-00229
The Defendant appeals a judgment entered by the Blount County Circuit Court awarding the Plaintiffs discretionary costs including attorney fees. This appeal arises from an earlier action (second lawsuit) seeking specific performance of a settlement agreement resolving the original lawsuit filed by the Defendant.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Houston M. Goddard
Originating Judge:Judge W. Dale Young |
Blount County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Alexander C. Wells v. State of Tennessee
M2001-00144-COA-R3-CV
Appellant, Dr. Alexander C. Wells, was a professor at Tennessee State University ("TSU"). He was relieved of his teaching duties in 1992 and was asked to remove his property from the office and laboratory space he occupied at TSU. He moved some of his belongings in 1995. His remaining belongings were boxed and moved to the campus warehouse in 1996 because the space had been reassigned. When he retrieved his belongings in 1997, he found several items missing. Appellant then brought a claim in the Tennessee Claims Commission asking the State of Tennessee to return his property or, in the alternative, give him monetary compensation for the lost items. The Commission held that TSU had not been negligent in the care, custody and control of appellant's property. Therefore, the State was not liable for the missing property. We affirm the decision of the Commission.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Ben H. Cantrell
|
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Flora Mae Melton v. Glen Houston Melton
2001-00128-COA-R3-CV
Originating Judge:J. Russ Heldman |
Lewis County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Cultra Landscaping Supply Company, v. Director of HIghways, Department of Transportation and W.L. Sharpe Contracting Company, Inc. and Charles Hill, Individually and D/B/A C.H. Hill Landscape and Excavating
02A01-9512-CV-00275
This is an action by the appellant, Cultra Landscaping Supply Company (Cultra), seeking to recover the balance allegedly due on an open account. Cultra’s complaint, as amended, was filed against the Director of Highways, Department of Transportation, W. L. Sharpe Contracting Company, Inc. (Sharpe) and Charles Hill, individually and d/b/a C. H. Hill Landscape and 2The Director of Highways was named as a defendant pursuant to T.C.A. § 54-5-124 (civil actions against contractors by claimants). Cultra’s complaint states that it “seeks no remedies” against Sharpe, but acts to put the latter “on notice” of said claim having been filed with the Department of Transportation. Prior to trial, a summary judgment was entered in favor of Sharpe. The order granting summary judgment provided that the State of Tennessee and the Department of Transportation were to retain certain funds to satisfy Cultra’s claim in the event it proved meritorious at trial, in accordance with T.C.A. § 54-5-123. After trial, an agreed order was entered with this Court dismissing the Department of Transportation, Director of Highways as a party. 2 Excavating (Hill). For purposes of this appeal, however, the only other party before us is Hill, the appellee.2 A bench trial resulted in a judgment for Hill. Cultra appeals on the sole basis that the evidence presented at trial preponderates against the trial court’s findings. For reasons hereinafter stated, we affirm.
Authoring Judge: Judge David R. Farmer
Originating Judge:Judge Robert L. Childers |
Shelby County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Loretta Trull, v. Margaret Culpepper, Commissioner of Tennessee Department of Employment Security, and Kerr Plastic Products, Manpower Temp Svcs., et al.
02A01-9603-CH-00041
This is an unemployment compensation case. Petitioner, Loretta Trull, appeals from the order of the chancery court dismissing her petition for certiorari and affirming the decision of the Board of Review that disallowed her claim for unemployment compensation benefits.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge W. Frank Crawford
Originating Judge:Judge George R. Ellis |
Crockett County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Glenn T. McColpin, v. North Atlantic Casualty & Surety Insurance Company, Inc.
03A01-9602-CH-00067
This is a suit for damages against an insurance company for the alleged breach of a lawyer’s professional liability insurance policy. Plaintiff, Glenn McColpin, appeals from the judgment of the chancery court for the defendant, North Atlantic Casualty & Surety Insurance 2 Company, Inc. (hereinafter, “North Atlantic”).
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge W. Frank Crawford
Originating Judge:Chancellor R. Vann Owens |
Hamilton County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Bobby R. Reed, v. National Foundation Life Insurance Company and Mark Bradshaw
03A01-9603-CV-00081
This is a Rule 9 appeal from a judgment denying the defendants’ motions for summary judgment. The issue is whether an insurance agent has the apparent authority to waive the conditions for issuance of a policy and the limitations on his authority as contained in the application for the policy. We hold that the agent has no such authority and therefore grant the motions for summary judgment.
Authoring Judge: Senior Judge William H. Inman
|
Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | ||
Thomas A. Smythe v. Phil Jones, et al .
M2000-02062-COA-R3-CV
In this suit wherein the Plaintiff, Thomas a. Smythe, seeks damages against the Defendant, Donald Cowan, for willfully interfering with contractual relations between Mr. Smythe and Phil Jones, the Trial Court granted summary judgment because in his opinion the Statute of Limitations barred the claim asserted. We affirm.
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Houston M. Goddard
Originating Judge:Judge Russell Heldman |
Williamson County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Michael Daniel Fry v. Yuriko Shinoda Fry
M2000-02969-COA-R3-CV
Pursuant to the wife's motion under Rule 60, Tenn. R. Civ. P., the trial court amended the division of the husband's Navy pension contained in an agreed order of divorce. We reverse the trial court's judgment.
Authoring Judge: Judge Ben H. Cantrell
Originating Judge:Judge Muriel Robinson |
Davidson County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Mary Kindred, On Her Own Behalf, And as Next of Kin of Marcus Briggs, v. The Board of Education of Memphis City Schools, et al.
02A01-9512-CV-00280
In this wrongful death action, Plaintiff-Appellant Mary Kindred (Plaintiff), on her own behalf and as next of kin of Marcus Briggs, appeals the trial court’s judgment entered in favor of Defendants-Appellees Board of Education of Memphis City Schools, Willie Anderson, and Raybon Hawkins (Defendants).
Authoring Judge: Judge David R. Farmer
Originating Judge:Judge Robert A. Lanier |
Shelby County | Court of Appeals | 12/05/01 | |
Patricia Broadwell, v. Thomas Michael Broadwell
03A01-9607-CV-00242
This is a domestic relations case. The issues are whether the evidence preponderates against (1) an award of alimony in futuro to the appellee, (2) the finding that an alleged loan to the parties was intended as a gift, (3) an award of attorney’s fees.
Authoring Judge: Senior Judge William H. Inman
|
Hamilton County | Court of Appeals | 12/04/01 | |
Mike G. Pauley, v. Madison County, Madison County Penal Farm, David Woolfork, Madison County Sheriff, Penal Farm Superintendent, Captain Jackson, et al.
02A01-9607-CH-00161
Plaintiff, Mike G. Pauley, an inmate at the Madison County Penal Farm (Penal Farm), appeals from an order of the trial court dismissing his pro se complaint against the defendants, 1 Plaintiff filed suit against Madison County, Madison County Penal Farm, David Woolfork, the Madison County Sheriff and Penal Farm Superintendent, Captain Jackson, the Penal Farm’s Head Controller and Acting Warden, Sergeant Jered, the first shift sergeant, Sergeant Evans, the third shift sergeant, Officer Steven Horner, and Officer Cleo King in their official and individual capacities. 2 4which include Madison County, the Penal Farm, and several of the Penal Farm’s personnel.1
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge W. Frank Crawford
Originating Judge:Chancellor Joe C. Morris |
Madison County | Court of Appeals | 12/04/01 | |
State of Tennessee, v. Robert Willis Chance, Jr.
02C01-9605-CC-00178
The appellant, Robert Willis Chance, pled guilty to one count of second degree murder and one count of attempted first degree murder. Pursuant to the plea agreement, the sentences were to be served concurrently. The Hardin County Circuit Court imposed a sentence of twenty-three years for each conviction. In his sole issue, the appellant contends that the trial court erred in imposing twenty-three year sentences because of the misapplication of Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-35-210 (1995 Supp.), regarding the presumptive sentence of a class A felony.
Authoring Judge: Judge David G. Hayes
Originating Judge:Judge C. Creed McGinley |
Hardin County | Court of Appeals | 12/04/01 | |
State of Tennessee, v. Michael Anthony Pike
02C01-9509-CC-00261
The Appellant, Michael Anthony Pike, appeals as of right his sentences for simple possession of marijuana, possession of marijuana with intent to sell, and possession of drug paraphernalia. He argues on appeal that the trial judge erred by not placing him in community corrections or, in the alternative, by not giving him the minimum statutory sentences. After a careful review of the record on appeal, we affirm the trial court’s judgment.
Authoring Judge: Judge William M. Barker
Originating Judge:Judge Julian P. Guinn |
Henry County | Court of Appeals | 12/04/01 |