Court of Criminal Appeals Opinions - 4^th Quarter 1999

---

The following Tennessee Court of Appeals Opinions are available for download:

---

Cases Posted the Week of 12/27/99
State vs. Jimmy D. Johnson - 03C01-9903-CC-00102 - 1999-00146-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Dennis J. Shelton, Jr. - 03C01-9903-CR-00098 - 1999-00101-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Don Palmer Black - 03C01-9812-CR-00424 - 1998-00055-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. John Walter Sullivan - 03C01-9905-CR-00206 - 1999-01985-CCA-R3-CD View
John Barron vs. State - M1998-00031-CCA-R3-PC View
State vs. Johnnie Shane Capley - M1999-00353-CCA-R3-CD View
Ronald L. Davis vs. Jack Morgan, Warden - 01C01-9902-CC-00031 View
State vs. Shirley R. Hastings - M1998-00466-CCA-R3-CD View
David Stovall vs. State - M1999-00937-CCA-R3-PC View
State vs. Scott Wyatt and Angela Thomas - M1998-00470-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Robert P.Baucom, Sr. - 1998-00457-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Jack Rondal Dillmon - M1997 00080 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Jerry Wayne Ford - M1998-00462-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Dennis J. Hughes and Suvonnya Smith -M1997-00084-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. William M. Neely - M1998 00259 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Joseph Gray - M1998 00256 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Lonnie Dunn - 03C01-9809-CC-00332 -E1998 00515 CCA R3 CD View
Michael Glen Brice vs.State - 03C01-9807-CR-00267 -E1998 00436 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Ronnie Gardner - 03C01-9901-CC-00194 -E1998 0030 CCA R3 PC View
State vs. Kai Nielsen & Betty Nielsen - 03C01-9807-CR-00233 -E1998 00525 CCA R3 CD View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 12/20/99
State vs. George Cantrell, III - M1998-00104-CCA-R3 CD View
State vs. Edward D. Coffee - M1998-00472-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Harold W. Daniels - M1999-00303-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Howard D. Hickman - M1999-01829-CCA-R3-CD View
Danny Ray House vs. State - M1998-00464-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. James A. Adams - M1998-00468-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Kevin Burns -M1998-00449-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. John E. Cox, Jr. - M1998-00460-R3-CD View
State vs. William Davis, Jr. - M1999-01738-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Vernon Elkins, Jr. - M1999-00707-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Joseph Gieck - M1998-00467-CCA-R3-CCD View
State vs. Ricky Dale Langford - M1999-01740-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Donald Ray Pannell - M1999-00178-CCA- R3 CD View
David Stanley vs. State - M1998-00028-CCA-R3CD View
State vs. Brett Townsend -M1998-00026-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Bobby J. Young - M1998-00402-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Glen H. Earls - M1998-00447-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Donielle House - M1998-00403-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Joshua Meininger -M1998-00437-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Jesse C. Minor -M1998-00424-CCA-R3 CD View
State vs. Troy S. Sales - M1998-00012-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Paul Max Quandt, Jr. - M1998-00446-CCA-R3-CD View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 12/13/99
State vs. Ralph Dean Purkey - 03C01-9902-CC-00082 / E1999-01864-CCA-R3-PC View
Terry Stogdill vs. State - 03C01-9904-CR-00136 / E1999-01833-CCA-MR3-PC View
State vs. Stephen Dillard - 03C01-9903-CR-00100 / E1999-00020-CCA-R3-CD View
Frederick Zonge vs. State - 03C01-9903-CR-00094 / E1999-00144-CCA-R3-CD View
William Luttrell vs. State - 03C01-9901-CR-00004 / E1998-00017-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Molly Miles - 03C01-9812-CR-00447 / E1998-00453-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Ronald White - 03C01-9902-CC-00073 / E1999-00155-CCA-R3-CD View
Michael Stamm vs. State - 03C01-9810-CR-00376 / E1998-00452-CCA-R3-PC View
Robert Brewington vs. State - M1998 00420 CCA R3 PC View
Bobby Kenneth Nash vs. State - M1998 00406 CCA R3 PC View
State vs. James Tyree - M1998-00401-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Tyrone Vanlier, Sr. - M1998 00415 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Jeremy Whitson - M199800413 CCA R3 CD View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 12/06/99
State vs. Walter Allen - 03C01-9807-CC-00257 / E1998-00416-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Ralph Moore, Jr. - 03C01-9904-CR-00133 / E1999-00067-CCA-R3-CD View
Estil Green vs. State - M1999 01434 CCA R3 PC View
William Drumbarger vs. State - M1999 01444 CCA R3 PC View
State vs. Bryan Murray - M1998 00343 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. David Kearney - M1998 00376 CCA R3 CD View
Steven Douglas Tutt vs. State - 01C01-9905-CC-00155 View
State vs. Ronald Wayne Smith - M1999 01439 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Michael Powers - M1998 0026 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Victor Cazes - W1998-00386-CCA-R3-PC View
State vs. Edward Gentry, Jr. - 03C01-9905-CR-00215 / E1999-00056-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Joe N. Anderson - E1998-00378-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Joe N. Anderson - E1998-00378-CCA-R3-CD (Concur) View
State vs. Rhonda Burkhart - M1998 00344 CCA R3 CD View
John Seals vs. State - 03C01-9903-CC-00114 / E1999-00152-CCA-R3-PC View
State vs. Arthur Copeland - E1999-00044-CCA-R3-CD View
State - vs. Ronald Cross - E1999-00364-CCA-R3-CD View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 11/29/99
State vs. Donald & Kimberly Higbee - 03C01-9808-CR-00286/ E1998-00349-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Michael Dean - 03C01-9901-CR-00043 / E1998-00135-CCA-R3-PC View
State vs. Johnny Meeks - 03C01-981-CR-00411 / E1998-00251-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Michelle Franze - 03C01-9812-CC-00417 View
State vs. Jimmy Davis - 03C01-9901-CC-00008 View
Tray Turner vs. State - 03C01-9902-CR-00088 View
State vs. Jimmy Lackey - 03C01-9902-CR-00057 View
State vs. Macarthur Coffey - 03C01-9908-CR-00293 View
State vs. Tina Earls - 03C01-9901-CC-00025 View
State vs. Cecil U. Cobb - 03C01-9811-CR-00420 View
State vs. Adam Colzie - M1998 00253 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Price - M1999 01384 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Linda Cross - 03C01-9810-CR-00358 / E1998-00327-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Frederick Turner - 03C01-9906-CR-00222 / E1999-00010-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Donald Wallace - M1999 00954 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Kenneth R. Allen - M1999 00963 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Michael Braxton - M1998 00255 CCA R3 CD View
Ronald L. Davis vs. State - M1999 00965 CCA R3 PC View
State vs. James Freeman - M1998 00182 CCA R3 CD View
State vs. Andrew Lay - M1998 00257 CCA R3 CD View
Jackie McLaney vs. State - M1998 00187 CCA R3 CD View
Melvin Sawyer vs. State - 01C01-9811-CR-00440 View
John T. Sullivan vs. State - M1999 00969 CCA R3 PC View
State vs. Hugh R. Latham, Jr. - 03C01-9902-CR-00077 / E1999-00043-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Colin Steen - 03C01-9811-CR-00419 View
Charles Dwight Farrar vs. State - 01C01-9810-CC-00393 View
State vs. Michael Honeycutt - 01C01-9801-CR-00033 View
State vs. Joseph Price, III - 01C01-9810-CR-00421 View
State vs. Michael A. Braswell - 01C01-9807-CC-00304 View
State vs. Richard L. Meyer - 01C01-9902-CC-0034 View
State vs. George Pilkinton - 01C01-9809-CC-00368 View
Larry Anthony Wade - 01C01-9809-CR-00378 View
Cyrus Wilson vs. State - 01C01-9811-CR-00448 View
State vs. James Wright - 01C01-9811-CC-00476 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 11/22/99
State vs. Allen Cutshaw - 03C01-9711-CC-00521 / E1997-00041-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Raymon Romines - 03C01-9904-CR-00161 / E1999-00083-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Larry Trueblood - 03C01-9905-CR-00175 / E1999-00139-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Thomas Chambers - 03C01-9902-CR-00054 / E1999-00119-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. David Calloway - 03C01-9808-CR-00324 / E1998-00298-CCA-R3-CD View
State vs. Conley Fair - 03C01-9810-CR-00362 View
David Earl Miller vs. State - 03C01-9805-CR-00188 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 11/15/99
State vs. Candra Ann Frazier - 03C01-9904-CC-00146 View
State vs. Ira Babb, Jr. - 03C01-9811-CR--00415 View
Reece Loudermilk vs. State - 03C01-9810-CR-00352 View
Harold Mays & Bill Narramore vs. State - 03C01-9904-CR-00126 View
State vs. Charles Elsea, Jr. - 03C01-9901-CR-00031 View
State vs. J.D. Edward Ealey - 03C01-9902-CR-00075 View
Ronald Anderson vs. State - 03C01-9903-CR-00109 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 11/08/99
State vs. David Lee Hurst - 03C01-9901-CC-00011 View
Malcolm Crowell vs. State - 03C01-9812-CC-00441 View
State vs. Ricky Atkins - 03C01-9812-CC-00432 View
State vs. Jamie Lee Hatcher - 03C01-9812-CR-00428 View
State vs. Marsha Trentham - 03C01-9811-CC-00405 View
Mark Griffis vs. State - 03C01-9811-CR-00397 View
William Logan vs. State - 03C01-9808-CR-00287 View
State vs. Eric Larez - 03C01-9810-CR-00379 View
State vs. Curtis Ely - 03C01-9806-CC-00215 View
State vs. Curtis Ely - 03C01-9806-CC-00215 (Concur) View
State vs. Curtis Ely - 03C01-9806-CC-00215 (Dissent) View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 11/01/99
State vs. Tommy Lee Baldwin - 03C01-9810-CR-00365 View
State vs. Troy Godwin - 02C01-9811-CC-00364 View
State vs. Alvin Harris - 02C01-9804-CC-00118 View
State vs. Ardie Jackson - 02C01-9810-CR-00318 View
State vs. Kenneth Pickens - 02C01-9901-CR-00010 View
State vs. Jerrell Livingston - 02C01-9903-CC-00084 View
State vs. Bufford Barrett - 02C01-9901-CC-00023 View
State vs. Johnny Moffitt - 02C01-9904-CC-00142 View
State vs. Lorenzo Perry - 02C01-9901-CR-00005 View
State vs. Maurice Shaw - 02C01-9811-CC-00363 View
State vs. Curtis Watkins - 02C01-9808-CR-00236 View
State vs. David Eaton - 02C01-9802-CR-00043 View
State vs. David Frazee - 02C01-9809-CC-00291 View
State vs. Christopher Love - 02C01-9809-CR-00281 View
State vs. Ben Ray - 02C01-9901-CC-00021 View
State vs. Tina/David Wade - 02C01-9810-CC-00312 View
State vs. Richard Walker - 02C01-9901-CR-00006 View
State vs. Joyce Lindsey - 02C01-9804-CR-00110 View
State vs. Fred Smith - 02C01-9906-CC-00185 View
State vs. Jimmy Matlock - 02C01-9902-CC-00079 View
State vs. Carlos Porto-Saes - 02C01-9901-CR-00030 View
State vs. Marshall Simon - 02C01-9902-CC-00069 View
State vs. Bailey Agnew - 02C01-9901-CR-00015 View
State vs. Tyler Banes - 02C01-9812-CC-00378 View
State vs. Ricio Conner - 02C01-9807-CR-00201 View
State vs. Phillip Howell - 02C01-9901-CC-00018 View
State vs. Brian Williamson - 02C01-9810-CR-00305 View
State vs. Charles Evans - 03C01-9901-CR-00124 View
State vs. Steven Deadrick - 03C01-9806-CR-00219 View
State vs. Donald Green - 03C01-9808-CR-00276 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 10/25/99
State vs. Wanda E. Davis - 01C01-9811-CR-00446 View
State vs. Derrick Jenkins - 01C01-9811-CC-00467 View
Dwayne Gentry vs. State - 01C01-9904-CC-00117 View
Daniel Taylor vs State - 01C01-9904-CC-00132 View
Kerry Lovett vs. State - 01C01-9907-CC-00249 View
State vs. John Melson - 03C01-9712-CC-00531 View
State vs. Allen Hoyle & Bobby Godsey - 03C01-9803-CR-00122 View
State vs.John Thomas Heflin - 01C01-9809-CC-00380 View
State vs. Bruce Holder - 01C01-9902-CR-00054 View
State vs. Gary Moore - 01C01-9711-CC-00545 View
State vs. Jeffrey W. Osborne - 01C01-9807-CC-0092 View
State vs. Shelia Sharpton - 01C01-9903-CC-000105 View
State vs. Jeffrey Walker - 01C01-97905-CC-00200 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 10/18/99
State vs. Jimmy Thornton - 03C01-9811-CC-00384 View
State vs. Charles Eric Goodwin - 03C01-9808-CR-00275 View
State vs. John W. Wilcox - 03C01-9808-CR-00314 View
Henry J. White, Jr. vs. State - 03C01-9812-CR-00444 View
State vs Kenneth Storey - 03C01-9805-CR-00173
State vs. Blainey D. Zachary - 01C01-9810-CR-00442 View
State vs. William R. Begley, III - 03C01-9810-CR-00359 View
State vs. Paris A. Weaver - 03C01-9902-CR-00052 View
State vs. Matthew Fitzgerald - 03C01-9809-CR-00339 View
State vs. Craig S. Bourne - 03C01-9807-CR-00235 View
State vs. Jeffrey Lindemeyer - 03C01-9808-CR-00284 View
State vs. Jeffrey Lindemeyer - 03C01-9808-CR-00284 (Concur) View
State vs. Kenyetta Fields - 03C01-9805-CR-00178 View
State vs. Kenyetta Fields - 03C01-9805-CR-00178 (Concur/Dissent) View
State vs. Tommy S. Franklin - 03C01-9802-CR-00062 View
State vs. Steven Nicely - 03C01-9805-CR-00174 View
State vs. Cary Caughron - 03C01-9903-CC-00104 View
Bobby Wilcoxson v. State - 03C01-9804-CR-00134 View
State vs. George Raudenbush - 03C01-9811-CR-00409 View
Frank Barnard vs. State - 01C01-9807-CR-00296 View
William H. Horton vs. State - 01C01-9704-CR-00132 View
State vs. Kenneth Johnson - 01C01-9809-CR-00372 View
Tommy Lee Kelley vs. State - 01C01-9811-CR-00452 View
State vs. Delbert G. Mosher - 01C01-9807-CC-00320 View
State vs. Donald K. Moore, Jr. - 01C01-9809-CR-00362 View
State vs. Harold Woodroof - 01C01-9809-CR-00361 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 10/11/99
State vs. John Wayne Slate - 03C01-9511-CC-00352 View
State vs. Ronnie Mason - 03C01-9809-CC-00328 View
State vs. Carlos Mathis - 03C01-9807-CC-00249 View
State vs. Ricky W. McElhaney - 03C01-9804-CR-00162 View
State vs. David Proffitt - 03C01-9901-CR-00026 View
State vs. Danny Lynn Porter - 03C01-9811-CR-00393 View
State vs. Guy William Rush - 03C01-9805-CR-00193 View
State vs. David E. Hancock - 03C01-9808-CR-00278 View
State vs. James E. Frazier - 01C01-9801-CC-00036 View
State vs. Jason Kennedy Frazier - 01C01-9812-CC-00484 View
Avery Norris vs. State - 01C01-CR-00322 View
Daniel L. Sanders vs. State - 01C01-9712-CC-00586 View
Alvin L. Smith, Jr. vs. State - 01C01-9808-CC-00343 View
Richard Waline vs. State - 01C01-9805-CR-00199 View
State vs. Reginald Cobb - 01C01-9810-CR-00400 View
Charlie W. Dunn and Joyce Watkins -01C01-9504-CR-00119 View
State vs. Jerome P. Lyons - 01C01-9812-CC-00485 View
Hubert R. Fritts vs. State -01C01-9906-CC-00207 View
State vs. Marsh Barham - 02C01-9904-CC-00128 View
State vs. Patrick Ford - 02C01-9902-CC-00057 View
State vs. Victor Jordan - 02C01-9710-CR-00409 View
State vs. Ruth Stanford - 02C01-9812-CC-00365 View
State vs. Ruth Stanford - 02C01-9812-CC-00365 (Concur) View
State vs. Kelvin Young - 02C01-9809-CC-00287 View

---

Cases Posted the Week of 10/04/99
State vs. Robert Goldston - 03C01-9811-CC-00388 View
State vs. Ronald D. Correll - 03C01-9809-CC-00318 View
State vs. Jimmy Salyers - 03C01-9803-CR-00093 View
Alfonzo T. Peck vs. State - 03C01-9809-CR-00329 View
State vs. Timothy V. Bowling - 03C01-9805-CR-00167 View
Rocky Hipps vs. State - 03C01-9807-CC-00237 View
State vs. Dennis Wade Suttles - 03C01-9801-CR-00036 View
State vs. Harold Dufour - 03C01-9902-CR-00063 View
State vs. Glen Porter - 03C01-9808-CR-00294 View
State vs. James Gilbert - 03C01-9808-CC-00303 View
Ronnie G. Oliver vs. State - 03C01-9806-CR-00198 View
Charles Gaylor vs. State - 03C01-9702-CR-00066 View
State vs. John Mcbee, Jr. - 03C01-9811-CR-00413 View
State vs. Benjamin C. Ashworth - 03C01-9902-CC-00065 View
State vs. Clayton Turner - 03C01-9805-CR-00176 View
State vs. James Harbison - 03C01-9808-CR-00271 View
State vs. William Carpenter - 03C01-9711-CR-00504 View
State vs. Leonard G. Harvey - 03C01-9806-CC-00214 View
Gary Len Rollins vs. State - 03C01-9808-CR-00296 View
State vs. Jason Burns - 01C01-9809-CC-00371 View
Arthur Ray Lepley - 01C01-9903-CR-00084 View
Richard Carlton Taylor vs. State - 01C01-9809-CC-00399 View
State vs. Patrick Thurmond - 01C01-9802-CR-00076 View
State vs. Toussaint Turner - 01C01-9901-CC-00007 View
State vs. Mark Gesner - 01C01-9902-CC-00033 View
Lucy Killebrew vs. State - 03C01-9809-CR-00320 View
State vs. Johnny Leach - 03C01-9810-CR-00373 View
James K. Robbins vs. State - 03C01-9903-CR-00095 View
Jacques Bennett vs. State - 03C01-9809-CR-00338 View