Court of Appeals Opinions - 4^th Quarter 1998

---

The following Tennessee Court of Appeals Opinions are available for download:

---

Cases posted the week of 12/28/1998
Culbert vs. Carter Co. - 03A01-9801-CV-00018 View
Estate of Purnie Allen - 02A01-9808-PB-00232 View
Ernest Atkins vs. Security Life Co. - 02A01-9710-CV-00257 View
John Brantley vs. Robery Mayo - 02A01-9710-GS-00261 View
Adrian Pate vs. State - 02A01-9803-BC-00060 View
Carolyn Vatter vs. Robert Vatter - 02A01-9707-CV-00141 View
Kimbrough Dunlap vs. Patricia Dunlap - 02A01-9712-CH-00320 View
Elenia Gray vs. Estate of Charles Gray - 02A01-9803-PB-00061 View
Cassandra Lipscomb vs. John Doe - 02A01-9711-CV-00293 View
Genevieve Dix vs. James Carson - 02A01-9704-CV-00093 View
Estate of Gladys Tipler - 02A01-9707-PB-00173 View
Leanna Avery vs. Roger Lewis - 02A01-9805-CV-00123 View
Larry Granderson vs. Lisa Hicks - 02A01-9801-JV-00007 View
John Hogins vs. Tony Ross - 02A01-9804-CV-00102 View
Theo Jennings vs. Illinois Co. - 02A01-9803-CV-00056 View
Elizabeth Sorrell vs. Larry Henson - 02A01-9609-JV-00212 View
Mary Dowdy vs. Myles/Arlene Wilson - 02A01-9709-CV-00237 View
Frady vs. Ladd -03A01-9803-CV-00097 View
First Tenn. Bank vs. Webb -03A01-9801-CH-00011 View

---

Cases posted the week of 12/21/1998
Crowell vs. Hasty - 01A01-9609-CH-00431 View
Gilliam vs. Jones - 01A01-9801-CH-00031 View
Kidd vs. Hawthorne - 01A01-9808-CV-00413 View

---

Cases posted the week of 12/14/1998
Phillips vs. Lieb - 03A01-9806-CV-00186 View
Lawson vs. State - 03A01-9806-BC-00185 View
Sammons vs. Miller - 03A01-9803-CH-00094 View
Dubberly vs. Lynn Truck - 03A01-9808-CH00254 View
Davenport vs. Davenport - 03A01-9804-CV-00154 View
Banks vs. Polk Co. - 03A01-9807-Cv-00213 View
Jan Waters vs. State - 03A01-9808-BC-00248 View
City of Chatt. vs. Classic Ref. - 03A01-97120CV-00552 View
Elam vs. Seivers - 03A01-9805-CV-00165 View
Maddox vs. Co. of Loudon - 03A01-9802-CH-00074 View
Belew, In Re. - 03A01-9807-CH-00206 View
Mifflin vs. Mifflin - 03A01-9804-CV-00118 View
USI vs. Long - 03A01-9707-CV-00268 View
J.C. Bradford vs. Southern Realty - 02A01-9801-CH-00006 View
Palmer vs. Dept. of Correction - 01A01-9712-CH-00731 View
McKinley vs. Traughber and Byrd - 01A01-9804-CH-00205 View
Home Builders Assoc. vs. Maury Co. TN & Burson - 01A01-9706-CH- 00259 View
Dixon vs. Bryan - 01A01-9707-CV-00371 View
Durham vs. Durham - 01A01-9803-CV-00129 View
In Re: Carlton Agib Blessing, deceased - 01A01-9712-CH-00691 View

---

Cases posted the week of 12/07/1998
Beatty vs. McGraw et al - 01A01-9701-CV-00046 View
Reynolds vs. Board of Parole, et al - 01A01-9701-CH-00016 View
James Hancock et ux vs. U-Haul Co. of TN - 01A01-9801-CC-00001 View
County of Benton vs. Enviro. Serv. , 02A01-9802-CH-00040 View
Jeri St. John vs. Beer Bd. , 02A01-9804-CH-00095 View
Todd Harmon vs. Janet Harmon - 02A01-9709-CH-00212 View
Patsy Johnson vs. James Johnson - 02A01-9703-CH-00069 View
Steve Makris vs. Bob Kapos - 02A01-9712-CH-00318 View
Chase Serv. vs. Brandon Apparel - 02A01-9803-CH-00055 View
Dennis Crouse vs. Charlane Crouse - 02A01-9712-CV-00312 View
State vs. Lorenzo Pfeifer - 02A01-9811-CC-00307 View
Mayers vs. Miller Medical Group, et al - 01A01-9802-CV-00101 View
Moore vs. Moore - 01A01-9708-CV-00444 View
Lien vs. Couch et al - 01A01-9609-CV-00398 View
Permanent General vs. Waters et al - 01A01-9712-CV-00720 View
Kopels vs. Bryant - 01A01-9711-CV-00646 View
Gehl Corp. vs. Johnson - 01A01-9803-CH-00165 View

---

Cases posted the week of 11/30/1998
Hasty vs. Throneberry - 01A01-9709-CV-00531 View
Pawlakos vs. Pawlakos - 01A01-9708-CH-00443 View
Hogan et al vs. Coyne International Enterprises Corp. - 01A01- 9712-CH-00733 View
In re Estate of Louise C. Davis - 01A01-9803-PB-00157 View
Flowers vs. Horner - 01A01-9806-CH-00315 View
In the Matter of: Katelyn Nicole Viar - 01A01-9806-JV-00275 View
Wing vs. Wing - 01A01-9712-CC-00752 View
Lindsey v Coulter 03A01-9612-CV-00397 View
Harte Thomas vs. Shair Lab - 02A01-9711-CH-00289 View
City of Chattanooga vs. Hutsell - 03A01-9803-Cv-00105 View
Newport vs. Newport - 03A01-9712-JV-00543 View
Spruce vs. Spruce - 03A01-9807-Cv-00211 View
Johnson vs. Craycraft -03A01-9803-CH-00114 View
Olen vs. Altherr - 03A01-9806-CV-00166 View
Troy vs. Herndon - 03A01-9707-CV-00271 View
Betty Prather and Carol Prather vs. Kenneth R. Lyle and Holt Farms - 01A01-9711-CV-00663 View
Maples Homeowners Assoc., Inc. vs. T & R Nashville LP - 01A01-9608-CH-00368 View
Amy Tyler vs. Larry Morgan, d/b/a Larry Morgan Const. Co. et al - 01A01-9711-CV-00661 View
Amy Tyler vs. Larry Morgan, d/b/a Larry Morgan Const. Co. et al - 01A01-9711-CV-00661 (Dissent) View
Miles vs. Nelson - 03A01-9711-CH-00500 View
Malcolm Mills, et al vs. Ken Hancock, Ind., et al - 01A01-9803- CV-00162 View
Monroe E. Davis vs. Donal Campbell, et al - 01A01-9712-CH-00755 View
Creative Research Mgt, Inc. vs. Barry Soskin, et al - 01A01-9808-CH-00016 View
State Farm vs. John White - 02A01-9802-CV-00044 View

---

Cases posted the week of 11/23/1998
Reagan vs. Malone - 03A01-9805-CH-00173 View
Shorter vs. Shorter - 03A01-9802-DR-00054 View
Newsome vs. Quality Body Shop -03A01-9710-CV-00491 View
Parman vs. Swatzell - 03A01-9808-CH-00258 View
Westwood vs. Moore - 03A01-9805-Cv-00155 View
Beam vs. United Services - 03A01-9802-CH-00055 View

---

Cases posted the week of 11/16/1998
Jan Cagle vs. Steve Cagle - 02A01-9710-CH-00265 View
Jenkins Subway vs. Lynn Jones - 02A01-9801-CH-00001 View
Carolyn Love vs. Shelby Co. - 02A01-9803-CV-00053 View
Devona Mills vs. Immual Mills - 02A01-9711-CV-00295 View
Dick Moore vs. GreenTree Financial - 02A01-9707-CV-00148 View
Antwyan Pryor vs. Southbrook Mall - 02A01-9709-CV-00217 View
Dannenhold vs. Knoxville Pathology Group - 03A01-9710-CV-00443 View
Bradford vs. Anderson et al - 01A01-9712-CV-00689 View
Sommerville vs. Sommerville - 01A01-9710-CV-00559 View
Dept. of Human Services vs. Fineout - 01A01-9710-JV-00582 View
Blick vs. Kent - 01A01-9708-CV-00393 View
Baltz vs. Knight - 01A01-9606-JV-00263 View
Barnett vs. Barnett - 01A01-9605-CH-00228 View

---

Cases posted the week of 11/09/1998
Moyers vs. Albert - 03S01-9803-CH-00093 View
Steele vs. Superior Home Health -03A01-9709-CH-00395 View
Robertson vs. Robertson - 03A01-9711-Cv-00511 View
McManamay vs. McManamay - 01A01-9802-CH-00081 View
McManamay vs. McManamay - 01A01-9802-CH-00081 (Concur) View
Crowder vs. Laing - 03A01-9801-CH-00083 consol.with Laing vs. Crowder 03A01-9801-CH-00013 View
Wilkins vs. Dodson, Parker, Shipley, Behm & Seaborg et al - 01A01-9707-CV-00299 View

---

Cases posted the week of 11/02/1998
Meadows vs. Meadows - 01A01-9801-CH-00054 View
Brenda Campbell vs. Charles Campbell - 02A01-9711-CH-00286 View
Thomas Campbell vs. Ruth Campbell - 02A01-9803-CH-00073 View
Regenia Ellison vs. Cherri Ellison - 02A01-9803-CH-00054 View
Guardsmark vs. Borg-Warner - 02A01-9409-CH-00207 View
Smith vs. Smith - 01A01-9802-CH-00068 View
Eddie Cook, et al vs. Edwards et ux - 01A01-9712-CH-00705 View
McCormack vs. McCormack - 01A01-9707-CH-00341 View
State ex rel, Deborah D. Willis vs. Cecil Willis, Jr. - 01A01-9804-JV-00175 View
Phyllis Brown vs. Charles Brown - 02A01-9709-CV-00228 View
Phyllis Brown vs. Charles Brown - 02A01-9709-CV-00228 (Concur) View
Virginia Woolsey vs. Douglas McPherson - 02A01-9706-JV-00125 View
Kennedy vs. Robson - 01A01-9707-CV-00343 View
Lescarbeau vs. Lescarbeau - 03A01-9706-CV-00215 View
Fowler vs. Bowie - 03A01-9801-CV-00021 View
Pleasant vs. Repass - 03A01-9804-CH-00117 View
Moore vs. Moore - 03A01-9708-CH-00382 View
Frizzell vs. Gatlinburg - 03A01-9805-CH-00161 View
Wagner vs. Tabor - 03A01-9805-CV-00159 View
Jackson vs. Dotson - 03A01-9804-CH-00132 View
Bowles vs. Adams - 03A01-9803-CV-00113 View
Caruthers vs. Caruthers - 03A01-9712-PB-00539 View
Sanjines vs. Sanjines - 03A01-9808-CV-00253 View

---

Cases posted the week of 10/26/1998
Anne Galloway vs. University Club Memphis -02A01-9705-CV-00103 View
Roger Brown vs. City of Memphis - 02A01-9803-CV-00069 View
G. Winston Gragg vs. Nellie Gragg - 02A01-9804-CV-00108 View
Loyal Featherstone Constru. vs. Robert Coleman - 02A01-9709-CH-00213 View
Bob Souder vs. Health Partners - 02A01-9712-CH-00321 View
Margaret Barnes vs. Bright Glade Home - 02A01-9801-CV-00011 View
Allen Lawrence vs. Town of Brighton - 02A01-9801-CV-00020 View
Becky Sanders vs. George Gray/John Curtis - 02A01-9710-CV-00268 View
United Steelworkers of America vs. Air Pollution Control Board - 01A01-9605-CH-00235 View
Lance vs. Lance - 01A01-9801-CV-00036 View
Thompson vs. Thompson - 01A01-9712-CV-00695 View
Smith vs. Kelley - 01A01-9711-CH-00657 View
Griffin vs. Griffin - 01A01-9802-CH-00084 View

---

Cases posted the week of 10/19/1998
Ledford vs. Ledford - 01A01-9701-CH-00029 View
Hobbs vs. Hobbs - 01A01-9801-CV-00015 View
Coker vs. State Claims Comm - 01A01-9806-BC-00318 View
Beal vs. Sloan - 01A01-9801-CV-00024 View
Ford vs. Ford - 01A01-9611-CV-00536 View
Holifield vs. Campbell - 01A01-9806-CH-00291 View
Ingram vs. Earthman - 01A01-9510-CH-00439 View
Lynn vs. Blue - 01A01-9712-CH-00704 View
The Sherwin Williams Co. vs. Huddleston - 01A01-9711-CH-00651 View
Young vs. Young - 01A01-9801-CH-00047 View
Mierzejewski vs. BS - 03A01-9802-CH-00044 View
Adams vs. Adams - 01A01-9711-CV-00626 View
Fox vs. City of Dover - 01A01-9803-CV-00122 View
Irwin vs. Irwin - 01A01-9803-CH-00128 View
Lifetime Books vs. Thomas Nelson - 01A01-9708-CV-00399 View
Poole vs. State - 01A01-9802-BC-00104 View
Rayburn vs. Rayburn - 01A01-9710-CH-00548 View
Solima vs. Solima - 01A01-9701-CH-00012 View
Stancliff vs. Stancliff - 01A01-9802-CH-00078 View
On the Matter of James Lee Adams et al - 01A01-9709-JV-00476 View

---

Cases posted the week of 10/12/1998
Jamie Hamilton vs. Gary Cook - 02A01-9712-CV-00324 View
Jimmy Hawkins vs. Dennis Ellis - 02A01-9708-CH-00203 View
Randy Watkins vs. Vicki Watkins - 02A01-9708-CH-00178 View
ATS Inc. vs. James Kent - 02A01-9802-CH-00038 View
Max Norton vs. John McCaskill - 02A01-9712-CH-00325 View
Bond vs. Belle Meade Fund Partners - 01A01-9802-CV-00059 View
Davidson - et al vs. NCM Financial Corp. - 01A01-9712-CH-00743 View
Garrard vs. Metropolitan Gov't. - 01A01-9803-CV-00117 View
Helson vs. Cyrus - 01A01-9802-CH-00091 View
Logan vs. Logan - 01A01-9711-CH-00660 View
Logan vs. Logan - 01A01-9711-CH-00660 (Concur) View
Metric Partners Growth Suite Investors vs. Nashville Lodging - 01A01-9712-CH-00723 View
Peltz vs. Peltz - et al - 01A01-9711-CH-00659 View
Read vs. Home Depot USA - Inc. - 01A01-9803-CV-00121 View
Rhoden vs. Dept. of Correction - 01A01-9711-CH-00636 View
Throneberry Properties et al vs. Allen - 01A01-9710-CH-00612 View
Turner vs. Donal Campbell et al - 01A01-9802-CH-00089 View
Wallace vs. Wallace - 01A01-9712-CC-00751 View
Williams vs. Williams - 01A01-9709-CV-00522 View
Williams vs. Williams - 01A01-9709-CV-00522 (Concur) View
Joel Summers vs. Lisa Summers - 02A01-9709-CH-00230 View

---

Cases posted the week of 10/5/1998

Mohan vs. Mohan - 01A01-9708-CV-00415 View
Mohan vs. Mohan - 01A01-9708-CV-00415 (Dissent) View
Hartman vs. Univ. of Tennessee - 01A01-9804-BC-00196 View
Relford vs. DeRochie - 03A01-9712-CV-00547 View
Pilcher vs. Moneymaker - 03A01-9710-CV-00482 View
Adkins vs. Keck - 03A01-9804-CV-00141 View
Crye vs. Norton - 03A01-9804-CV-00142 View
Kratochvil vs. Kratochvil - 03A01-9712-CH-00536 View

---

Cases posted the Week of 09/28/1998
Chester Kelly vs. Jerry Wooten - 02A01-9712-CV-00305 View
Charlotte Thompson vs. Ralph Coulter - 02A01-9708-CV-00200 View
Robbie Hendrix vs. Billy Hendrix - 02A01-9712-CH-00303 View
Beverly Julian vs. Philip Julian - 02A01-9709-CV-00229 View